This is the bio of one of the most dangerous people in modern parenting:
Harry H Harrison Jr. is a New York Times best-selling parenting author with over 3.5 million books in print. He has been interviewed on over 25 television programs, and featured in over 75 local and national radio stations, including NPR. His books are available in over 35 countries throughout Western Europe, Eastern Europe, Norway, South America, China, Saudi Arabia and in the Far East.
The fact that there are more than 3.5 million copies of his parenting books in print – books that today’s parents might use to shape their children – is very scary.
I had never heard of Harry until yesterday when I stumbled across his article, “Dads Are From Mars, Moms Are From Venus,” and at first I thought it was a satirical article akin to the kind you find on “The Onion.” After all, what else was I supposed to think when I read the following about how men and women are changed by the challenges of parenting:
“The father is no longer the gentle caring new age male she fell in love with, but instead a caveman who believes his kids are sucking him dry and would toss them to the wolves at the first opportunity. The mother is no longer the sexy thing he married, but a delusional, gullible, mother hen who believes her poor 18-year-old baby can do no wrong, even if he’s in handcuffs.”
A caveman who would toss his kids to the wolves? I don’t think so, pal. And “a delusional, gullible, mother hen?” I needn’t explain to anyone how shockingly sexist that is.
I read on, thinking things could only go up from there, but, well…
“Dads want their children, especially their sons, to grow up. It’s a mom’s tendency to hand out money and comfort to children like it’s candy, whereas a dad will demand his children go to work. Like he did. When he was 10.”
Oh, you silly, little women, coddling your babies forever! Also, working at 10, Harry? Where did you grow up? Dickensian England?
Then there was this gem:
“Moms feel sorry for their kids. They are convinced their children are working too hard in school, that teachers don’t understand them, that they risk social harm because they don’t have an iPhone and they cannot possibly get a part-time job as that would mean life would be totally un-fun and so you, Dad, need to raise their allowance.”
As well as this one:
“Moms don’t believe in discipline. That’s why their greatest threat to their kids is, “I’m going to tell your father,” and often her kids can talk her out of telling Dad anything. She will be upset when you lay down the law because you clearly have no understanding how wonderful your child is, despite the fact she was caught cheating by three teachers.”
And let’s not forget:
“Moms say ‘yes’ to everything. This is why kids will always ask their mothers instead of their fathers for money, for a gold card, for a $1,000 new purse, or for a later curfew. The only time Mom will say “no” is when her husband begs her to quit saying ‘yes.’”
Man, you silly girls are impetuous! It’s like the world is filled with nothing but millions of Lucy Ricardos! How do we men ever deal with you?
Upon finishing the “article” I saw the bit about Harry’s having “3.5 million books in print.” A chill went down my spine. Could there be 3.5 million parents out there raising their children based on this pap? I clicked over to Harry’s website to do some more investigating and quickly found this description of good dads:
“But number one, they were men. They didn’t act weak or wimpy when it came to making difficult decisions. They had no compunction about laying down rules, dress codes, study hours, grade requirements, behavior policies. They stood up to a sympathetic mother. They brooked absolutely no back talk, language or arrogance from their daughter. They stood up for teachers, they let boyfriends know really bad things would happen to them if something happened to their daughter, they demanded the best out of their daughters – and wonder of wonders, they got it. Their daughters were actually afraid of their fathers’ wrath.”
That’s right, men! To be a good dad you better stand up to those darned “sympathetic mothers.” As for the bit about a “father’s wrath,” puh-lease, Harry. I want my daughter to respect me because I am just and wise, not because she is scared crapless of me.
Lastly, there was this:
“Our kids depend on us to make them laugh. I’m sorry but moms are not known as being entertainment centers. As one girl told me, ‘There’s nothing funny about mom, but dad cracks us up.’”
Ah! The women aren’t funny myth! Good for you, sir! You have left no sexist cliche unturned. Perhaps we should tell this guy Amy Poehler is a mom, and that she’s pretty funny. So is, for that matter, my wife and the vast majority of the other women in my life.
Here’s the thing… Harry believes that, deep down, we men and women are unchanged from our caveman ancestors and always will be. But I like to give us more credit. I believe we have evolved since those caveman days (heck, we have evolved since our parent’s generation), and we are better for it as men, women, and parents. Harry surely would disagree, but after clicking around his website it’s pretty clear he doesn’t believe in evolution of any kind.
Harry may think he’s got things figured out – and it is scary to think how many people may have bought his books and took his words as gospel – but what Harry doesn’t seem to understand is that the only result of his antiquated style of parenting will be a new generation of macho, distant a-hole men and frivolous, unfunny women who can’t be trusted with the checkbook or to lay out any discipline. And you know what? That might be the world Harry wants to live in, but it sure isn’t mine.
Reading this crap masquerading as how-to-be-a-dad advice makes me so upset because it only reinforces stereotypes that limit a man’s potential as a father. It is so important that modern Dads like myself get out the message that we can be more than just Ward Cleaver. We don’t have to turn in our “man card” if we are emotionally available to our kids or help around the house (just as there is nothing wrong with a mom who brings home the bacon or is the disciplinarian). In my home Heather and I are equals, both in making money and taking care of Annie, and we want her to learn that there is nothing she can’t do because of her sex. We have evolved. Today there are many different types of parents doing a great job (including married, single, straight, and gay), and all of our kids are lucky to have us.
Kelly says:
Right on Mike! As a parent of many years standing (and lying in a fetal position too), I can tell you that this sort of crap raises its ugly head every few years hand in hand with the “spare the rod, spoil the child” BS.
Happily, you are correct. We have evolved and our sons and daughters can expect their fathers to be loving and their mothers to be funny and archaic notions on parenting to be pointed out by fabulous folks like you. Represent!
Elizabeth Armstrong says:
I do believe this guy is crazy about his parenting techniques but “spare the rod, spoil the child” is in the bible. Now I don’t believe in abuse because I was an abused child. I rarely ever spank my kids because 99% of the time I find other techniques to be more useful. I think parenting should be equal on the mom and dad. My husband has a full time job and I am a stay at home mom. When he gets off he tries to take them the rest of the night so I can have some time for me and so he gets time with them too.
Summer says:
It’s actually not said in the bible. Perhaps you we’re thinking of Proverbs 23: 13-14.
“Do not withhold discipline from a child; if you beat him with a rod, he will not die. If you beat him with the rod you will save his soul from Sheol.”
Mrs Catch says:
This is my first comment here, though I have been reading you guys for a while. I just wanted to give you a big cheer. Well said. That guy is indeed very scary. Our kids deserve better.
Becca Masters says:
What a load of crap!!
My parents are nothing like what that guy is suggesting. It was always my mom that disciplined and say no and always my daddy who I went to when I wanted money, rides etc.
Even now, being 28, it’s still my mom that rules the house and my daddy who gives me everything I ask for!
Stephanie says:
Man, I think my parents didn’t get the same memo he did. My mom has an awesome sense of humour, said No to me ALL THE TIME “the nerve of her!” and did not hand me her money like it grew on a tree in the back yard! She was also the primary bread winner with an amazing salary, benefits, etc.. My dad on the other hand, well he also was cabable to say No, but he always took me out on Sundays to get lunch, and never intimidated me in order to gain respect. He also worked hard for his money and was just the best dad that I could ask for.
Does this Harry H Harrison Jr. even have kids? Because if he does I CAN’T wait until THEY write a book on “Growing up with a Crazy Father, and Brainwashed Mother” (The brainwashed mother is assuming that his dream “wife” really exist)
Amber says:
Right on Mike!
Reading this and the article you linked to made my jaw drop to the floor.
People actually pay for his crap?
And I’m with Becca–I can’t really speak for my own parents growing up because that was a bit of a unique situation…but I definitely see Becca’s way with my grandparents and other families. My grandmother is a very sweet woman, and my grandfather can have a really bad temper–but she always had to put her foot down and be the bad cop. My mom’s parents are similar–her dad’s always go with the flow do whatever you want so long as it’s not illegal and my grandmother is strict as all hell and would not hesitate to smack your bottom with a wooden spoon. I’m not saying these are pictures of ideal parenting at all, but REAL parents are much more dynamic.
I know all those campy 50s sitcoms portrayed stereotypes of Moms and Dads as Harry describes, but reality isn’t a 50s sitcom. His writing plays so closely to the stereotypes it’s absolutely absurd. How could anyone read that drivel and think he was describing actual people and behaviors? No one “mom” or “dad” is as one dimensional as he describes.
Deirdre says:
I haven’t seen ( or heard of ) this book or author before this but from the quotes you gave, it almost seems too far out there to be real. Is it possible the entire thing is intended to be satire?
Mike says:
That’s what I thought at first too… it has to be satire! But this guy has a large website with his articles and links to his many books on Amazon and other places, so it is pretty clear he is for real.
gugs says:
Mike – According to his Amazon bio he is a copywriter and principal at a consultancy firm. This is like the woman who wrote “The Secret” or whatever that drivel was (you know the one where if you will it and make pin boards it will happen). She used to be television writer and producer for Channel 9 (A TV station here in Australia). Her greatest achievement before The Secret came out was the TV show “The World’s Greatest Commercials”. These people are not qualified but are very good at “repackaging” and “rebranding” into an easily swallow-able packaging for gullible/trouble people or people that just don’t know any better.
Megan says:
This guy is spouting a load of crap, but you want to see a *really* scary parenting book? Try ‘To Train Up a Child’ by the Pearls. *Shudder*
Michelle says:
Ohemgee, so true! Someone actually GAVE my husband and I that book when we were super young parents of our first child and told us that if we followed it, we’d succeed at parenting. *Shudder* is right!!!
defendUSA says:
In my house, I am the hard-ass, he is hero and comforter. I have 4 great kids and I don’t have to read a neanderthal parenting book to know that love, discipline and teaching right from wrong will stand the test of time.
Amber says:
Gah, needed to pop back in to point out this quote too:
“2. Dads have this genetic thing about providing for their family. They worry all the time about money. So while you think he’s being stupid by freaking about the cost of diapers or formula… and later college and cars, what’s really happening is he’s worried sick about providing.”
Yes, because us women are so frivolous and clueless that we toss money around willy nilly without a care in the world for costs or practicality.
I know this is petty and perhaps not nice–but who would trust a guy named “Harry H. Harrison Jr.” anyway (I’m tempted to wonder if his middle name is Henry or Harold or some other such derivative). I kid, of course…but not only did his grandparents saddle his dad with a thoroughly repetitive and weirdly contradicting name: Harry Harry’s Son (literal meaning of Harrison)…but his parents continued the tradition…and named him after his father 3 times over.
Meghan says:
I haven’t heard of this guy either, but whoa! I do not know a single family that operates this way, either in my personal group of friends, family, or through my job as a social worker. He is so off base, its frightening.
Amber says:
Okay, last comment, promise–but I was compelled to check out this guys website (I’m procrastinating, but also weirdly fascinated that this guy even exists). I was curious about some of his other views. I felt like there were some pretty clear jabs in the article at same sex couples…:
“Children need the fun play of Dad, as well as the nurturing of a mom. They need the discipline of a dad, as well as the un-judgmental support of Mom.
The fact is, while tension between Mom and Dad is inevitable, it’s worked for thousands and thousands of years. Both parents just need to realize a healthy child needs what both parents are genetically equipped to give—love in their own way.”
Whether the jab is intentional or not…such assertions make my skin crawl.
I also found this gem in his bio:
“I also have strong views about faith which irritates some people but it’s their offspring clogging the juvenile system.”
I actually had to reread that a few times to realize he was actually saying what I thought he was saying…
Mike says:
I caught that “gem” you mentioned too, Amber, and I too had to re-read it a few times. Unbelievable. Statistics have actually shown that the vast majority of prisoners in American jails are believers. I would have to imagine the statistics for kids in the juvenile system are not that different.
BUT IT IS OF COURSE repugnant and offensive to draw a correlation between belief and crime, just as it is to draw a correlation between secularism and crime.
The answer to keeping kids on track isn’t as simple as whether they do or don’t go to church/temple/etc. It is far more complex
TonyaM says:
That’s about the stupidest thing I’ve read in I don’t known when. Of all the good cop/bad cop parents I know, MOM is usually the tough one. I know I am, as was my own mom. You want something? Bypass Mom! Dad’ll say yes! And then there are the tougher dads, and then there are the families where the only tough one is the kid who is running the show.
And you’re right, daddies have evolved so. My husband and brother get comments all of the time raving about what good dads they are. They ARE, but they get bragged on because they took a baby to a basketball game and let mom take a nap. Or because they do daycare drop-off, or change a diaper, or listen to a child read her library book. REALLY?! I call all of that PARENTING. Nobody ever told me what a good mom I was when I had a baby out by myself…..Anyway, I had an awesome father, so I don’t want to say fathers are better now. Just….more involved.
Sue Rissel says:
WOW that’s thick. Those stereotypes are more the exception rather than the rule.
I do have to say that my husband and I started working young, but he worked on dairy farms and I had a paper route… hardly sweat shop work and our children do not have those options. Not that I would let MY daughter deliver papers by herself in this day and age. Nevermind that I survived four years of it unscathed.
I am a “mean mom” because I set rules and enforce them.
There are so many wrongs I could address but I am happy to say that I never bought into any parenting expert’s advice. Period. I stopped doing that once I learned that Dr. Spock’s son committed suicide (I think it was him). Then I realized that parents can only do the best they know how but as long as their children are loved, cared for, and taught right from wrong then we are doing our jobs.
We can debate minor details in 3.5 million OTHER parenting books and still not agree on a standardized method of parenting. And that’s something I’m proud of.
Rachel says:
Just FYI, it was Dr. Spock’s grandson who committed suicide, and he had long suffered from schizophrenia.
This Harry Harrison Jr. sounds like someone who sees the world only in relation to his own opinions and theories, rather than basing his theory on what he sees now, in the real world. Some of what he says sounds as though it describes the gender roles my grandparents’ generation were expected to follow — but didn’t necessarily follow — but it certainly doesn’t describe my parents’ generation (Boomers) or mine. No doubt Harrison would answer that that’s because Dr. Spock’s book messed up the Boomers and it all went downhill from there. Whatevs.
For me, I want to act in the best interests of my child and that involves knowing him, loving him, teaching him, and treating him as an individual rather than following anybody’s one-size-fits-all parenting advice, and my husband does the same.
Shannon says:
This cannot be for real!
Mike says:
I know, right? But it is very real, I’m afraid. Scary!
Brandy says:
Holy freaking crap. That’s insane! It’s sad that there are people out there like this and that they have a loud enough voice for others to hear. Your article was great though and I’m glad fathers and mothers are definitely involved and evolved these days. And hopefully this guy’s message will get smaller and smaller.
madge says:
A) I am funny.
I say no WAAAAYYYY more than I say yes.
C) My kids are well-behaved and respectful because BOTH their parents hold high standards and work as a team.
This guys is patently insane as is anyone who buys his book.
LizL says:
What’s the hook? This book was written in 1950, right?
Mike says:
No hook… Harry is writing this stuff today!
Molly says:
Love this post!
Linn says:
Ha, he obviously didn’t write this from any research done at my house .
Meyli says:
uggggggg…. -_____-
thank you Mike, for being a good person!
cindy w says:
I’m going with “3.5 million people think this crap is HILARIOUS,” because I have no other way to explain those book sales. That’s just baffling.
cynthia says:
Well apparently he is very popular in “Western Europe, Eastern Europe, Norway, South America, China, Saudi Arabia and in the Far East.” I’d bet ESPECIALLY in the latter, less so in the first few places.
Melli says:
Yikes
PhaedraH says:
As always Mike, thanks for sharing your view! It never gets old hearing from someone who enjoys parenthood and understands the responsibility attached to raising a child.
Ragan says:
I can’t find anywhere that says if he is actually a parent. Even his own bio doesn’t say it! If this is the case, I must laugh because I always find that it is the people without kids that are the quickest to tell you how you should be parenting…If he is a parent…I am assuming as soon as his kids hit 18 they run with no looking back. This is very sad.
Mike says:
I believe I saw him mention on his website (in his intro to his book on how to raise daughters) that he only had sons. So yay… coming soon to the world… more dudes like this guy!
Jenn says:
WHAT THE HELL?!?! Is the guy on crack or what?!? I feel so sorry for his kids – well, that is IF he even has kids….although, I can’t imagine why ANY woman would go for a guy like that!!! YUCK!!!
He might have printed 3.5 millon books but that doesn’t mean he sold even 1 of them!!! In my little humble opinion…. if any guy believes and/support this type of thinking, then he deserve to waste his money on such rubbish!!
Kay says:
This guy is bat-shit crazy. Despite having two parents, my mother was always the disciplinarian, jokester and everything in between. She’s the last person I would ever describe as “weak”. Hopefully those 3.5 million circulated copies are being left deep at the of bargain bins and moldy boxes in the attic where they belong.
Susan says:
I kept waiting for a line saying, “hey, this is only satire” to appear, and was disturbed that it never happened.
I can’t believe anyone is this out of touch with reality. His perception is ridiculously off, and even more alarming is that he is writing books like he’s an authority figure, and he’s selling a significant number of them.
Fear is one of the worst motivators. It’s always temporary, and just leads to resentment. Legitimate respect is harder to earn, but it lasts longer and means more.
RG says:
I was going to comment, but my head just exploded.
(PS I’m the disciplinarian in this house! My husband must secretly be a woman!)
Ali says:
WOW. This nutjob just goes to show you that the internet can truly hold ALL THE CRAZY IN THE WORLD.
What frightens me most about this particular brand of wackjob (other than the atrocious use of grammar) is the very thinly veiled misogyny. According to Harry, it’s appropriate to demand good grades and ‘proper’ behavior from a daughter, but what’s the end goal?
Apparently when she has a baby, she becomes a free-spending, placating pushover, so Harry, WHY bother educating her in the first place? Let’s just keep her home and teach her how to cook and clean, since that appears to be all she’s good for. Let’s save those dollars we would have spent toward her college education, and instead donate them to her future husband to offset her impending and unavoidable transformation into a shop-aholic.
@CindyW–I hope you’re right!
Ali says:
WOW. This nutjob just goes to show you that the internet can truly hold ALL THE CRAZY IN THE WORLD.
What frightens me most about this particular brand of wackjob (other than the atrocious use of grammar) is the very thinly veiled misogyny. According to Harry, it’s appropriate to demand good grades and ‘proper’ behavior from a daughter, but what’s the end goal?
Apparently when she has a baby, she becomes a free-spending, placating pushover, so Harry, WHY bother educating her in the first place? Let’s just keep her home and teach her how to cook and clean, since that appears to be all she’s good for. Let’s save those dollars we would have spent toward her college education, and instead donate them to her future husband to offset her impending and unavoidable transformation into a shop-aholic.
@CindyW–I hope you’re right!
Samantha F in St. Paul says:
I have a feeling this guy probably subscribes to the same school of thought as those crazies that protest at military funerals.
jacky says:
So Scary…..I agree he is SO wrong and so patronizing….. It is scary of people to think this….
Even if the bible says the spare the rod thing…. it also says to stone to death people who commit adultery and who desecrate the sabbath. Can’t just pick and choose what you want.
Arghh Mike, just Mike.
Pattie says:
I can’t even begin to wrap my head around what this parenting “expert” (COUGH) spews forth. Good-parenting tenets? Not so much as sexist, neanderthal sterotypes. I can only hope all those books that were printed remain unsold and are in a big old pile of paper waiting to be recycled.
Sarah says:
It really is scary that there are apparently people who believe in this garbage he is spewing. I honestly feel sad for their children.
Madi says:
Frightening, indeed, but this is actually really mild compared to some of the other crap out there.
Case in Point: Michael Pearl’s “To Train Up a Child”
http://www.amazon.com/Train-Up-Child-Michael-Pearl/dp/1892112000
That book openly advocates for and recommends child abuse.
Harrison’s work is definitely off point, but IMO, the generalizations are so broad that it just ruins any and all credibility. Combine that with simply awful writing and I imagine that anyone with any degree of common sense will see through the B.S. (That is, if they get through the first page!)
Unfortunately, I’ve had to read a couple of Harrison’s books and Pearl’s book, among others, as part of my thesis research. Reading Harrison’s writing was like slogging through mud, so I’m really not too concerned about him. I doubt many people actually make it through the entire book. (And I strongly suspect there are now 3.5 million new doorstops out there!)
It’s the strong writers like Pearl who get me concerned. And there are many, many others out there.
Authors like Pearl — who is a vastly better writer vs. Harrison — are truly frightening to me.
What more can we expect from someone named Harry Harrison? Give your kid the same first and last name (or pretty darn close) and this is what happens! I’m convinced it’s a sign of inbreeding. LOL
Unfortunately, this is the price we pay for our freedoms — the idiots are free to voice their opinions and theories too!
We can only bring light to their shortcomings — just as you’ve done here.
Best,
Madi
Auntie_M says:
This sounds like it was written about 100 years ago…and even then it was crap! So glad my brother and brother-in-law and, in fact, all of the men I know who are currently fathering youngsters haven’t run across this bit of bs but are parenting from the heart and with common sense! (That goes for you too, Mike!)
Nan says:
Haven’t heard of this guy, but THANK YOU for your take on him.
MECR says:
Scary! Unfortunately my husband was raised to think this by both his parents. I am making sure to raise my sons differently…..a WHOLE LOT differently.
Mommy says:
Great, another crazy believer to make the rest of us look bad.
This guy has completely lost touch with reality. His poor kids!