Even though I love what this time of year brings (pumpkins, 105 degree weather, etc), I’ve found myself really battling to keep my head above water for the last three Septembers. Another school year is starting, another year that Madeline isn’t with her peers. I’ve made excuses every year (It would be kindergarten! It would be her first year of all-day school!) but I just have to accept the fact that it’s going to be hard every year. Every year I will balance my excitement for Annabel and James with my sadness for Madeline. I feel like I should be better at this by now, but I have to remind myself often that it’s only been five years. It feels like a lifetime but when I look at the rest of my life stretched out before me, it’s only a blink.
I’m especially susceptible to outside influences when I’m going through a valley of grief, so I quite literally schedule time into my day to allow myself to decompress and let my mind “go there.” It sounds silly when it’s written out – that I have to schedule time to actively grieve – but if I didn’t, I would crack. I know that at the end of the day, I will be able to feel everything I’ve been pushing to the back of my mind. This lets me be present for my kids, meet my deadlines, and not get lost in flashbacks and panic attacks. I’ve been having a lot of flashbacks lately.
Over the years, I’ve been asked several times – mostly by nurses and palliative care professionals – what could have been done differently the day Madeline died. It’s one of those difficult easy questions, because I know the answer but to explain it, I am transported back to that day. The sounds, the smells…the fear…it all comes rushing back and threatens to overwhelm me. The things I saw in those three hours while they tried to save her are burned into my brain forever, and it is a daily struggle to keep them locked away deep in my mind. I stood there and watched them do insane, scary things to her tiny body and she still died. I watched her die. It was obviously as horrific as you’d expect, so horrific that it almost doesn’t feel real. But every morning when I wake up, I remember that it is real.
On the mornings where I feel like I might throw up from the weight of it all, I start employing all of my coping mechanisms. I schedule play dates so my kids can have fun and I have someone to talk to. I throw myself into party planning and focus on the tiny little details. I imagine myself on a tropical island, or in front of a fireplace, or at Disneyland or anywhere else I have happy memories with my family. I walk around with constant feelings of guilt and failure and I wish daily that I could relieve the last six years and do everything differently.
On the day Madeline died, I wish the doctors and nurses had let us hold her for her last moments. I wish I could have been holding and touching my daughter when she died instead of standing ten feet away, helpless. I wish I could have been closer to her, talking into her ear during her final breaths so the last thing she heard would have been our voices telling her how much we loved her. This could have happened for us and Madeline and it didn’t, and I am still upset about it (I have spoken with hospital personnel). I don’t like to talk about her last three hours alive but I am now with the hope that the nurses and doctors who read here can remember our experience the next time they are in this situation with a patient and family. When possible, a patient deserves to have her family there for the last moments. The family deserves it, too.
Katherine says:
Oh, sweet mama… Tears for you — and her. Sending lots of hugs and warm thoughts your way. I, too,wish things could have been different for you — very very different.
My parents had to watch my brother die. Even though I wasn’t there, and he was all grown up by then, my parents’ words still haunt me, and i still — twelve years later — have nightmares about it. So I can only imagine.
Much love and light and peace to you all…
Laura says:
beautifully written–what a legacy it would be for Maddie if doctors and nurses made it happen ??
Panni says:
I am so sorry. xxx
amourningmom says:
I so wish you were holding her too. We did hold Jake as he died but I am forever haunted by the image of Sawyer on a gigantic hospital bed (with tape on his mouth – but that is a different story). We were allowed to “see” him but not touch him.
Sending you hope and hugs. xoxo
Amanda says:
I cannot imagine how hard it is to articulate that you could not hold her. I hope there isn’t a shred of you that feels guilt for that. You were a constant in her life and I have no doubt she knew you were close.
I am so sorry, Heather. She was pure magic. Sending so much love.
MG says:
Thank you for speaking out on such a difficult thing to help others. All I have to say besides that is huge hugs to you.
Brandy says:
Thank you so much for sharing this. As a nurse I will take this to heart.
Tedra says:
I am a nurse too and I take this to heart as well.
MD says:
I’m a physician and I hear you loud and clear. This is a powerful message that we need to get other doctors and nurses to hear as well.
Martha says:
I had a granddaughter that died at 8 days old 22 years ago. Parents and grandparents were not allowed to touch or hold Lauran. We got to hold her at the funeral home! I still have her image in my mind. Thank God I have videos of her. I remember waiting on the freeway as the Neonatal ambulance rushed her to another hospital and see it go by. She coded 3 times before she arrived at that hospital. Love my little angel.
Nellie says:
I can’t even begin to imagine but my heart aches with pain for you while at the same time, fills up with so much love for you and your beautiful family!
Stephanie says:
I know how hard it was to write this, but it was so poignant and important. My heart breaks that you weren’t able to do hold your precious Maddie.
Valerie says:
My grief in no way compares to losing a child but I just wanted to share, in hopes of maybe letting you know you’re not alone. I struggle every day with the what ifs of my dad dying in January. My brain knows that there was nothing I could have done differently but I still wake up and feel guilt that I didn’t talk him out of having the treatment for the GBM I KNEW was going to kill him. Granted, it’s only been 8 months (to the day, actually) but I still relive it over and over again. He was in a coma for what they thought was a stroke in March of 2013 and I beat myself up every day that I didn’t let him go then.
I hope it doesn’t sound like I’m trying to one up or anything. It is so refreshing to know that other people dealing with grief have experienced the same things I am. Grief is such a strange thing, isn’t it? We have always been huge South Carolina Gamecock fans and the first football game, I cried like my dad had just died all over again because he wasn’t on the phone cheering with me.
Glenda says:
So sorry Valarie for your dad. I get what you are saying. My mom passed 10 yrs ago and it’s still just as hard if not harder. The other night as I lay down for bed I thought of her and a tear fell down my cheek. I miss her every day! I wish I can pick up the phone and share the good and bad with her.
Erin Christine says:
This just took my breath away. Absolutely unfathomable…I am so so sorry. Huge hugs
JoAnn says:
So achingly, beautifully written, Heather. I cannot even fathom the inner strength it took you to put those words “to paper” like this. Your speaking out helps so many. I wish you peace and serenity as you continue to find ways to journey through your grief…
Karen says:
I am so sorry Heather. My heart hurts for you and the pain you’ve gone through.
Jessica Stringer says:
All I can say is I’m so sorry. I cannot even begin to imagine the pain. Hugs
Anna says:
I hate that you have to go through this. In your weakness, you are so strong. Love and hugs to you!
Gwen says:
I am so, so sorry that you had to live through that, and have to live with it now. My heart aches for you, imagining it.
Lisa says:
Huge hugs.
kristen says:
I’m so sorry, for all of you, that those hours happened at all, and that they happened the way they did. Sending many virtual hugs.
JustAMom says:
This just breaks my heart. I am so sorry for what you have to go through on a regular basis. Being a mom is exhausting enough…… I can’t imagine what it must be like to be a mourning mom. Your dedication to all three of your children is amazing.
Jessica says:
Lots and lots of hugs
Lori R says:
You describe so well how you grieve, feel and think. As well as the methods you need to employ to cope. Your words are poignant. So sorry this is what you have to go through daily. So sorry it happened at all. No one better to speak to doctors and nurses on this issue. Hugs and love.
Nikki says:
I’m sorry.
Rian says:
Heather, this one took my breath away. You’re right. You and Madeline did deserve that. I’m so sorry you didn’t have that moment together.
Glenda says:
So sorry Heather & Mike! thinking of Maddie! xx
Michele says:
Heather, I am so sorry. I hope your words and messages will help medical professionals do better by other families — thank you for being willing to share such difficult memories.
Nadinsche says:
I am so sorry you could not hold her.
Molly says:
Hi Heather,
I’m so so glad you wrote this, because you shared what you’re going through. You’re not alone. First, I just wanted to say it’s not silly at all to literally schedule time to grieve every day–it’s inspiring. I’ve been told to do this myself for what I’m grieving and yet I don’t do so because I’m busy but also I’m avoiding it. But it’s so, so important. How can we allow ourselves to honor everything we lost if we don’t literally make the time, especially in your case when you have two little children to take care of?
Now the second thing ventures into the area of advice and I really hate giving that. I’m listening to you describe that last day of Maddie’s life–those hours–and I am hearing you that they truly haunt you. To me, this sounds like trauma. I am in treatment for PTSD, and I recognize what you’re saying: nightmares, flashbacks, triggers by sights and smells and times of year, as well as when you said how hard it is for you to talk or even think about those last few hours. Taking care of yourself with your coping skills is so essential, and that’s what’s going to get you through this. But if it turns out that you do have PTSD or PTSD-like symptoms, then a lot of this haunting won’t go away. There’s grief and then there’s trauma. The grief will always be there, but my god, when I think about what you went through, suddenly and unexpectedly losing Maddie surrounded by such coldness from doctors, that is a whole other aspect of awful. And there is specific treatment for that–things like EMDR and exposure therapy–that can actually help you be able to talk about that day and can actually ease the nightmares and flashbacks. I struggled for a long, long time because the sad fact is that most clinicians aren’t trained in how to treat trauma specifically. They just thought I was depressed or anxious and treated those symptoms, but then I finally learned that there are some therapists who know specifically how to treat people who have suffered traumatic events no one should ever have to go through–and suddenly losing your very young child is definitely traumatic. None of this might be news to you or helpful at all, but I just wanted to share how much what you’re saying makes sense in the lens of trauma, and that I’ve found that there’s hope for some relief from part of the suffering, even though the grief will never ever go away. And like you said, you’re only five years out. That is so, so recent.
Here’s some info re: PTSD; I hope you don’t mind my sharing.
http://www.helpguide.org/mental/post_traumatic_stress_disorder_symptoms_treatment.htm
Jolene says:
Thank you Molly. I too, was treated for severe anxiety and panic. And then we all realized it was the same triggers every year around the same time every year I would get worse. PTSD is not just for veterans and military personel.
Auntie_M says:
I don’t think it’s silly at all that you schedule time to grieve on a daily basis: in this busy world of ours it sounds downright HEALTHY. I am glad you take time to reflect on Madeline and her life and death and the wonderful blessing and great loss she is in your life. I think, especially since you are raising 2 more wonderful children and have the busy lifestyle that simply comes with that, making sure you have that time you need to reflect, grieve, and take care of your emotional health is absolutely essential to a healthy life. Good for you.
I cannot believe 5 years have passed…time is an odd thing.
I’m glad doctors and nurses have asked what could have been done differently…I think having a nurse to attend to the parents, to care for them & explain what is happening would be a good idea and am ever so grateful for the nurse who came to be with you out of love for Maddie and your family. I, too, wish you could have been close by to her, so she could have heard your voice and felt your touch. I hope medical staff listens to you and other parents, who have (sadly) been in your position.
Much, much love, dear one.
Suzanne L. says:
It seems so unfair that a mom should have to write what you did. Hugs to you. You held her so many times in her life, and I wish you had gotten to hold her then. A mom’s love is so strong and I believe she was being held by you even if it wasn’t physically.
Lia says:
Heather, I appreciate your bravery in writing about these difficult topics and shedding light on your perspective. I can’t imagine how you miss Maddie and how hard the days are without her. I am a NICU nurse and you teach me so much through your words. We always try to have babies be in their parents arms when they pass and if their parents can’t or choose not to be there and we have done all we can we will hold them during their last moments. I had a primary baby pass recently at a little over one years old up in the PICU. Thank you for writing and helping me to know how to better support her parents through this time. I miss her every day but can’t even begin to imagine the grief her parents must wade through daily. Much love to you.
AuntieMio says:
Dear Heather,
I ache when I read these posts. I am so glad you feel safe in this space to share these raw truths, but how I ache for your pain. And while I know that the pain will ebb with time, it will never be gone forever.
I am so sorry that in those last traumatic moments you were not next to her, touching her, whispering your perfect love for her in her tiny ear. I believe without question she knew you were there. But it is not the same is it? It is not enough.
As a peds onc ICU nurse I have been on the other side of your trauma too many times to count. That moment when everything in the room shifts and all of the sudden any illusion you have of control is taken and you are fighting and racing with everything you have to save someone’s child. And when it goes that wrong that fast you know that the likelihood that you will succeed is incredibly slim. And it is sickening.
I have been in that moment. And I always know when to tell mama and daddy to come to the bedside, to hold their child’s hand, to whisper love softly in their ear. I am so sorry that did not happen for you. I am so sorry. I don’t know if telling you this will hurt you or give you hope. I pray for the latter. I pray you know that this happens and that the nurses and doctors where Maddie was treated have learned from this. What a legacy for your little love, to teach professionals the value of mom and dad in the transitional moments. I wish she were here with you. I wish she had lived.
I admire your courage and strength I sharing your story, especially with the team who cared for her. We are not perfect people. We are humans and we make mistakes and if we do not learn from them we are arrogant fools. I promise that each and every time I find myself in that horrible situation on the other side of the bed I will remember Maddie and I will remember you and Mike. I will remember that I have been invited in to take care of someone else’s child and while I may know a great deal clinically, I can never know the heart of a family. It is a priveledge to care for someone’s child and I never want to forget that.
One last thing. My mama is 46 years out from the death of my brother (he was 6 when he died). This year his best friend became a grandfather. That is a milestone that she will never have with her son. It gets easier, but it never goes away. So keep writing Heather and keep feeling and sharing. It is the very best way to heal your fragile and broken heart.
RzDrms says:
I wish you could’ve held her too.
Sandy says:
I am so sorry to hear about the guilt you feel about the day yiur daughter died. I was an ICU nurse for 25 years and then the member of a team that went to all emergencies in the hospital for 5 years, so I have also been on the other side of the bed. I sometimes have mixed feelings about having family members at the bedside. Will it help them or make it more terrifying ? We have to do to many things quickly to a patient, some that may be painful to watch to try to help them. It is a brutal effort to try and beat back death and you have to bring every thing you know how to do to defeat it and it hurts us when we can’t . It is even harder when the patient is young. I know for myself and my patients when you know that your efforts are not going to work, I always tried to go myself or send someone to get the family so they could be with them in their final moments when the code is stopped. I think it is important to not be alone in your final moments. I have always stayed with my patients if the family cannot be there. It is a privelege to be with a patient, hold their hand, make them comfortable as they die.
I am a nursing instructor now and I will make sure to tell your story to them so they can advocate for their patients. You said you have talked to medical staff, but I again would talk to someone. Maybe they can change their procedures to make sure family can be present in a patients final moments , and also to make sure someone is assigned to a family such as a social worker, so you are not there alone without support and who can advocate on your behalf.
Again I am so sorry you are re-living the last 3 hours of your daughters life with such pain and guilt. Nothing I can say will make it any better except to say I’m sorry and I will say a prayer for your family.
eRin senge says:
Thank you for writing this. As impossible as it is for you to live, relive, and write about, and as hard as it is to read, I hope it helps you; it definitely helps me to read. I hope it helps other doctors and nurses make sure that other families don’t have these same painful regrets. I know that your words would give me the strength and bravery to better advocate for myself and my kids, and to demand what we need (though it’s not always clear at the time…).
Nat says:
You are so right, Heather. 1000% right.
Amelia says:
Whoosh. This just takes my breath away. Sending love.
Tami says:
Im so sorry Heather and Mike. When ever You talk about Maddie it brings tears to my eyes. It seems Like yesterday that you had to say good bye. My heart aches for both of you. I cant imagine standing there watching all that you had to watch and feeling so helpless and not being able to hold your child and Love her. I don’t think the pain will ever go away. It wouldn’t for me.. I pray that god gives you both the strength you need to make it threw these hard times. I also hope your experience will help other parents have a better way of saying good bye to their Child.. Hugs, Your both are in my prayers!!
Rachel says:
Words are just not enough. Nothing really is. My heart breaks for you and Mike and your family and especially Maddie. I wish it were different. I continue to pray for you all.
Paula says:
Heather, I’m so sorry. My heart aches for you and Mike. Thinking about your family today, specially your beautiful Maddie.
Katie says:
How absolutely heart wrenching… I can’t even imagine how awful that was. I am sure the problem comes down to legal issues, unfortunately. If they had let you hold her as she died, it would be as though they were giving up. It is sad that that is what the medical field has come to, but that is the only reason I can imagine why they didn’t let you hold her… and kept working on her instead. I can’t even fathom how this was for you… You deserved to hold her as she passed on. You were there when she was born. You deserved that moment. I am sorry. So very sorry…
Shaynee says:
Heather,
I am so sorry you have to write this, for a multitude of reasons.
When my daughter was two weeks past her second birthday, she had a respiratory illness that ballooned into a medical crisis in the space of a few hours. I called out-of-state family to say “if you’re going to come, do it now” as the crash cart rolled in and doctors struggled to figure out why she was so sick. She was shivering in my husband’s arms, chilled saline pumping into her veins to bring dwn her 106+ fever, as the time came to put her under. She started crying, “Mama, hold you” (her syntax was off because I always said, “Let Mama hold you” so that was her way of asking me to cuddle her), and I couldn’t, because of all the tubes in the way. I stood and stroked her head and kept telling her that Daddy had her and that I loved her, then she was unconscious. Eventually, after a couple of tense days, she pulled through. (It is unforgivably unfair that you cannot also write those words.) But even now, seven years later, I am in tears with guilt because I could not honor her request in those moments.
So there is no “supposed to be better by now.” My child is here, and I am still routinely reduced to a tearful wreck when I recall that day. Your family’s love for Madeline is profound. I wish you had less painful memories surrounding her final hours. Your words here will undoubtedly make a difference for some other family in their darkest hour. Hopefully that helps soften a minute corner of your grief.
Shaynee
Meg says:
Heather, I’m so, so sorry. Sending love to you.
Paula R. (fka preTzel) says:
Heather –
That would be my wish for you too.
I want to tell you that sometimes when I am driving to work in the morning and the sky is a bright pink/purple color I think of Maddie and say Good Morning Moo to her. I didn’t personally know your Maddie Moo but my heart is heavy with her loss. I don’t know how you and Mike have made it this far without her but I admire your strength and love for each other and others to keep supporting others that need it.
Take those moments of grief and remembrance. There is nothing wrong with it.
Katrina says:
Oh, Heather…
This is so, so hard and terribly unfair. I’m so sorry you didn’t get to hold her. My heart truly aches for you.
Nicolette says:
Heather, I sobbed for a very long time after reading this. I am so incredibly sorry for you loss. This was beautiful and haunting and incredibly brave. You and your family are in my thoughts and prayers.
Anon says:
You are so brave Heather, as was your darling girl, Maddie. Sending you love. Wishing you a good day tomorrow.
Karen says:
I am so sorry you have that pain to live with forever too and so sorry you can’t go back. I swear if I could invent one thing, time travel would be it.
Caitlin says:
I couldn’t agree more. For any health care professionals reading this – YES. I am one of the lucky ones. On my son’s last day, when we all knew there was nothing more we could do, the nurses moved mountains to let my spouse and I hold him ALL DAY. He was hooked up to so many machines that it took a team of 4 dancing, juggling nurses to hold him while we wiggled into position on the reclining chair. I don’t remember eating, or peeing. I do remember sweating with his little sticky body snuggled against my chest. I remember taking thousands of pictures (literally). I remember nodding to the doctor to take out the ventilator, and we held him, singing, praying, cooing, talking as he died over the next hour. And as crazy as it may seem to those of you who haven’t been there – I KNOW how lucky I am to have had that experience. Please, if it is in your power, give that gift to your patients’ families. Tell them if it’s time, that it’s it. And let them have those last few hours.
Marianne says:
Oh, Heather. I have no words. I am so very sorry for all that you and your family have been through. I just think you’re amazing.
Nadinsche says:
Heather, I just read this post again. I lost my grandmother two weeks ago. Even though it is a completely different situation than when you lost your beautiful little Maddie I am so sad as we were very close. My sister and I sat next to my grandmother when she died. We hold her hands and she might have heard our voices. And I am very thankful that we were with her. Now I can totaly understand what difference it makes to the patient and the family. And there are no words to tell you how sorry I am that the doctors and nurses did not make this possible for you. I wish you could have hold her. I am so sorry!