I was finally able to sleep on April 7th after I brought Annabel into bed to snuggle. I needed to rest my hand on her chest while it rose and fell, and I was lulled by the sound of her rhythmic breathing. In the morning when she woke up (over an hour later than usual!) she said, “Mama! I’m in your bed! How did I get here? Magic?” And that was pretty much the last adorable thing she said or did for the entirety of the day.
Annabel doesn’t understand April 7th or its significance to our family. She will, someday. In years past, Mike and I were as glum as we needed to be, but now that Annie is three she notices our moods. And while she’s seen us upset before (hell, I’m pregnant, daily crying is practically a requirement) and has reacted with compassion, she also reacts with questions. Most of the time, I answer these questions (it’s always fun to explain pregnancy hormones to a kid. “Mama’s crying because that commercial was just so sad.”), on the seventh Mike and I just didn’t have the energy.
I have this semi-vision for the future that April 7th will become a day where Madeline’s siblings do something fun in her honor. I honestly have no idea if this is something Mike and I will ever be able to do; Maddie’s birthday seems like a more fitting day for fun (especially since it’s a holiday so the kids will always be out of school). But we decided to give it a go on this April 7th. I just wanted to have a good day with Annabel. Play in the backyard, maybe go to the park, and have a nice dinner.
And she was just the worst.
I don’t know. Maybe she could sense that, try as we might, our hearts and minds were preoccupied. Maybe I should have left her in her own bed overnight. Maybe she was just being a three-year-old, with all the dizzying highs and hide-in-your-bedroom lows that come with being that age. On any other day I would have instituted epic time-outs, changed my plans, and gone about my day. But on this day, I kept trying even though I knew it would just end in disaster. I kept hoping that she’d snap out of her toddler funk because I needed my daughter. I also desperately needed to get out of the house and…it unsurprisingly didn’t end well.
On the one hand, she stressed me out so much that the awful day flew by. But on the other hand, I ended the day crying outside her bedroom door, feeling like a failure of a parent with one daughter who was unhappy and one daughter who was dead. Mom of the year.
When she woke up yesterday morning, she said, “Mama, Daddy! Today is going to be a good day!” As Mike said, she just reset overnight. Meanwhile, Mike and I were worn-out shells, and I had a hard time not holding a grudge. Against my three-year-old. Which is obviously so stupid and yet I was just so…I don’t know…disappointed. Mostly in myself, I think, for expecting my toddler to just magically understand we needed her to not have a bad day on the one day that was already bad.
Yesterday she told me she wanted to draw a heart in the sky because “I love you and daddy so much.” I know that I rely too heavily on Annabel…she saved me in her pregnancy and birth but I have to stop using her as a life-preserver. She’s just a kid who was born into a heavy situation. I hope that one day she looks back and understands all of this, and how precious she is to me. I would draw a thousand hearts in the sky for her.
Lilian says:
Aaah, this is just so sad, but be advised that yes, I do believe that toddlers can sense our moods and emotions, no matter how we try to disguise them! One day Annie WILL understand everything, and then, more importantly, the fact that you have kept up this blog, it is a legacy that you will have made for her (and the acrobat). Everything is in this blog, and one day, she will read it, and everything will make sense to her. In the meantime, trust in the fact that at 3 years old, she won’t remember too much from the occasional off day, but most of her memories will be from the good days. I believe that eventually the 7th can be a day of fun for Maddie’s siblings. You and Mike will make sure of that. Best advice given to
Lilian says:
oops, hit submit too early, but reading what I wrote, I think I’ve said what I wanted to say. Hang in there! xxx
Barbara says:
You two are just the most amazing oarents I’ve ever “met”. Humbling. Your girls are really lucky… Thank you for sharing.
Amanda says:
You are amazing parents to Annie. THAT’S what she’ll remember .
Auntie_M says:
Oh, I think you’re quite right about Annie picking up on the underlying emotions you & Mike were dealing with on the 7th…she probably felt it building, just as you do as the 7th approaches. But, try as you might, you can only fake the superficial top layer so much…those underlyng emotions will still be there and Annie is a very insightful child. For your sake, I wish she had responded by reverting to babyish needs for the day…but…3 year olds! Whatcha gonna do wi’ ’em???
Some day, I can see you celebrating Maddie’s birth together with cream puffs and pictures and videos. As well as observing Maddie’s passing with days of contemplation, and balloon or lantern releases, and pictures and videos…and maybe even more cream puffs. But my guess is that while Annie may “get” observing Maddie’s birthday even this coming Nov, it may be a couple years before she is ready for April 7th.
But, as frustrating as it was, at least the day went by quickly?
And on Monday, you & Annie had hearts to paint in the sky.
Such love between the 32 of you
Auntie_M says:
(Starting to hate my random not-so-smart-phone!)
Back to what I was saying….
There is such love between the 3 of you…and I for one read great significance into Annie wanting to paint hearts in the sky. Something tells me they would have been in shades of purple.
Remember:it’s ok to ask family or friends to watch Annie for you for a time should you and/or Mike need to really grieve — whether that means crying, watching Maddie videos or looking at pictures, sitting in silence, or shouting your lungs out without being interrupted by a 3-year-old…that’s ok! Doesn’t change your love for Annie, it’s just taking care of you too.
XOXO
Annalisa says:
I like that. There’s nothing wrong to let Annie know that sometimes mom and dad need some time to sort out feelings they themselves can’t fully explain.
My thought though is that Annie was just being a kid, which can be maddening to parents on the best of days, and is often magnified on the worst of days (I was having that sort of horrible day on Friday, myself). Letting family pitch in on that day would help ensure she can be herself while not accidentally stepping all over the raw feelings this day brings to the both of you.
Heather says:
I’m not even going to pretend to understand this level of grief. I know as the years go by the April 7ths will each present new challenges.
I imagine it would be difficult to make this day “fun” in the future, have you considered instead just settling for “kind”? Plant a tree, arrange to visit an animal shelter and offer to walk some of the family-less dogs. Make it your families ‘random act of kindness’ day and do kind things in Maddie’s honour.
Heidi says:
I love this suggestion.
Heather, you are a wonderful mom. And I so appreciate your honesty. My daughter is the same age as Annabel (to the day), and there are definitely some trying times. I cry and feel like a failure too after snapping at her over some typical little 3-year-old thing. It’s hard.
Argh. I hate that you are hurting so much. As other people have said, try to be kind and gentle to yourself, you are doing your absolute best and Annie is having a wonderful childhood.
Lots of love to you.
Erin Christine says:
Hugs, Heather! I’m so sorry that this was an even more challenging day. Please give yourself a break – you are only human and those are some heavy emotions to deal with. You and Mike are magnificent parents!
AmyG says:
Heather, I love how honest you & Mike are. I love how neither of you hide your feelings & don’t make parenting sound like it’s a breeze all the time. Because as you know… it’s not. Kids are funny & have ups & downs like we do. Their lives change every minute. Don’t beat yourself up over this day. “Today is going to be a good day!” (even if it isn’t) Thank you for being you & being honest!
Jess says:
I think our children sense our grief and know that we may not be “tuned into” them on those days, and as a result, act out. This always seems to happen to me on those hard days as well, and then you feel like the worst parent ever because you’re already so sad and then your kids acts out all day and you try not to yell, try not to disrupt them more, but it happens because they just.won’t.listen. I’ve had those days, but remind myself that they are just little and don’t understand. They are just craving your attention and want all the focus on them. It will pass. We are still good moms and we’re going to have bad days, even when it’s hard on our hearts. You’re not alone in this.
Mary says:
You are so completely opposite of a failure of a parent! All you can do is the best you can. Sometimes it won’t be exactly what you hoped for…and sometimes it will. I’m in the same camp as some of the other comments; Annie likely sensed your mood and stress and was commiserating with you both as best she could and the only way she knew how.
No regrets. You did what you could with April 7th this year. You are all tired, your bodies and your souls. I hope you can each get some rest and find whatever is needed to get some solace.
Hugs and moral support to your family.
Mary
Karen says:
Heather, be kind to yourself. You and Mike are amazing parents and Annie is so very loved. While I’ve never met you in person, your love for your children is so clear in everything you write.
Suzanne says:
Don’t feel so bad, you made it through that horrible day, give yourself credit for that. I think it’s good that you realize now that you had unrealistic expectations. It is hard for an understanding adult to know the right thing to say or do in a situation like this, let alone a toddler. Auntie M had good advice for future April 7ths. Be easy on yourself, let your parents and other family help you. There are many people who love you, even when you have a bad day, just remember that.
Lisa says:
I think she was just being a typical 3 year old. Their moods are so unpredictable and unexpected. You just never know when they are going to flip out into little crazy pants. She may have sensed how you and Mike were feeling. But my daughter is 5 and she still makes me nuts and has bad days. She had a bad entire week at VPK last week. Embarrassing. But it is a distraction, sometimes from things we do not want to think about when they act out. So maybe that is why she was having a tough day. To move things along and change the focus. I pray that time eases your grief and know that you will celebrate Maddie’s life with your beautiful family one day.
Jenn says:
“I ended the day crying outside her bedroom door, feeling like a failure of a parent with one daughter who was unhappy and one daughter who was dead. Mom of the year”.
Those words….they cut me like a knife and brought me to instant tears. I wanted so much to hop on a plane to LA and just grab you in my arms and hug you. Instead I instantly picked up my phone to text you but stopped myself b/c I didn’t want to wake you in case it chimes you when you get a text and at that point, it was WAY early in LA.
Heather, PLEASE be kind to yourself and be forgiving. It’s ONLY been 4 yrs since you lost one of the greatest loves of your life. I’m proud of you & Mike for even getting through the day AND for keeping Annie with you the whole day. You could have easily booked a babysitter or gave her to your parents for the day but you choose Not too. PLEASE, give yourself some credit!!!
Everyone has off days, even 3 yr olds who in all honestly probably did pick up on your sadness but you know what…that’s okay b/c the 7th IS a SAD day!!! I think it’s great you and Mike are going to try to make it a positive day in the future but Heather….if that doesn’t work out….if you just….can’t do it please know that’s OKAY TOO!!!
You and Mike are AMAZING parents!!! Both Maddie and Annie are very lucky to be your daughters and the new baby is lucky to be your son. Sometimes, I wish you could see yourself through my eyes….like how I SEE YOU!!! You would be SOOO PROUD of yourself if you did.
I know the 7th and the days leading up to it are full of sorrow and terrible memories so I am very happy everyone stepped up this yr. so you could feel the love around your family and Maddie and know that your beautiful little girl will ALWAYS be remembered.
If you get nothing more out of this post please get this…We all hurt and when we do the best thing we can do is just put one foot in front of the other, remember to breathe and somehow just get through it. You did that on the 7th and you didn’t give up – BE PROUD!!! What more can you ask for?
See, you REALLY ARE MOM OF THE YEAR and I for one am very BLESSED and HUMBLED to call you my friend!! xoxo
Lisa says:
The threes are tough, she will push you in ways you didn’t think possible. You are a great mom. I’m sorry the terrible threes made Sunday that much harder for you.
Love and hugs.
Panni says:
You are a GREAT mom. Sorry that you have to hurt at all. xxx
MG says:
Oh my gosh…I love you for this post. This is why I read blogs…you put into words what others feel. Thank you.
Jen D. says:
You and Mike are amazing, amazing parents and your love for your children is so beautiful. Annie is so very lucky to have you both. I can’t imagine how hard it must have been to deal with toddler melt downs on a day that is already so horrible.
As a daughter of parents who lost a child before my birth, and as someone who works in the missing children’s field where there are many left behind siblings, please be careful not to depend on Annie to help you through your grief. Every person is different, and I’m not sure how Annie will feel, but it is incredibly hard on children to feel like they need to buoy their parents during their grief over a lost child or to feel like they need to help fill a hole that is in their parents’ hearts. It can feel like you always have to be “ok” so that your parents can feel ok too. Also, Annie never met Maddie and just may not have the connection or feelings toward her that you want her to.
I know that you would never purposefully make Annie feel that way, and most parents don’t realize it when they do. It’s just something I’ve seen a lot and so that you can get any help you need to protect your other children.
Like I said, it is obvious to anyone that you are wonderful parents and that your children are all so lucky to have you. Love to you all as you navigate this life together.
I
alissa says:
This is such a true response.
Jessica says:
We celebrated my daughter’s fifth “angel day” not long ago and as my children have gotten older and time has passed it has gotten a little easier to make the day more light-hearted but it is still so draining and I want them to not fight and whine or do anything else that makes the day less than easy but they do anyway.
I know that I too rely on my kids to get me through but I’m not sure I agree with the commenter above. I don’t think our surviving kids will suffer from too much love from us. If we “rely” on them by holding them close and giving them extra kisses and hugs and just being happy that they are alive I can’t really see that as being a disservice to them one bit.
We do what we have to do to keep on going and you are doing just that.
Trisha says:
Cut yourselves a big break on this day and know that the raw feelings you get hit with are totally normal and immensely unfair but you made it through another April 7th. All you are required to do is just breathe.
Molly says:
You know, as I was reading this I was thinking, maybe Annie is mourning Maddie too. Sure, she didn’t get to meet her in person, but she knows all about her, and I’m sure somewhere she “knew” that yesterday was the day commemorating when Maddie died. And how would a child show grief? Through regressive behavior, that makes sense. Maybe she was mourning for *her own* loss. She couldn’t be compassionate to you, or make your day easier, because she has her own loss to grieve–the loss of a sister, the loss of a family that will always feel whole, like everyone is present and accounted for. And in a way, that could be Annie connecting with the sister she never knew. To connect with her, she has to be able to *both* celebrate her life *and* mourn her death.
I’m trying to think of a helpful family ritual for the anniversary of Maddie’s death. Maddie’s birthday can be a great time to celebrate her life, and the anniversary of her death can be a time to make space for sadness in your family. Which is a skill that will empower your kids throughout their lives. A craft might be helpful, especially since I know you enjoy crafts. My sister once had her kids make a construction paper chain for her son, their brother, who died. I like the idea of the chain–something that symbolizes connection on a day that’s all about a terribly broken connection. You could decorate each link in the chain for Maddie, and for each year that’s passed since she died, letting her know, in a way, that as the time passes, your whole family is still connected to her. Also, a construction paper chain is an EASY craft, which can be good during a time of year when it will always be hard to have any energy. Art therapists might have other ideas like this.
Christina says:
I think it’s okay to just feel terrible on this day, and try to figure out what to do and get it wrong sometimes. It doesn’t mean that is how it will always be. Don’t be too hard on yourself. If it was a friend going through this, wouldn’t you feel compassion for her and see what a wonderful person and mom she? I’m sure you would. Please try to give some of that love and compassion to yourself. You deserve it. You have raised 2 of the most bright, charismatic, engaging and memorable children I have ever known. Soon to become 3. You are constantly self-reflecting, always working to make things better for your family. You’re doing an amazing job.
Glenda says:
Be kind to yourself. You’re doing an amazing job. I hope when Annie and Mr. Acrobat are older you as a family can do something fun in honor of Maddie.
Keep your head up!
xo
Debbie B. says:
“feeling like a failure of a parent” Oh Heather, that couldn’t be farther from the truth. Please cut yourself some slack – especially on days like the 7th. I’ve raised four kids (now ages 21-27) and although I love them to bits and pieces there are, were and always be days where things between us just don’t mesh – but I’ve learned that that is okay. Go easy on yourself – being a Mom is one tough job, and sometimes we can be our own worst critics. You and Mike are amazing parents.
Tara says:
Oh Heather…my heart aches for you so much! I just know that one day Annie will feel so blessed to know how much she saved you and held you up and gave you a reason to keep going. It’s so hard when kids act up on days you feel especially broken. I’m so sorry this year had to be that way. I can only hope that next year will be so very different for you and Mike with a 4 year old and a precious son too. You guys are wonderful parents!
jacky says:
(((Hugs)) This whole situation sucks. You are great parents. Don’t beat yourself up. I am sure Annie picked up on your feelings. You are a great mom. How can April 7th ever be a good day? It just can’t.
Hugs, Light and peace
Jacky fromMD
Christine says:
Maybe it was God’s way of distracting you from feeling like complete shit all day! I know you love and miss Maddie, but even though it was the day she past, I’m pretty sure there will be another day within the 364 days of the year that you’ll mourn her! Take today to honor her passing instead! Light a candle and put it next to her photo. If you didn’t have the chance to do something fun then, do it now! Xo
Paula says:
It’s quite a comfort to other parents of three year olds that Annie has bad days! I am sorry your day wasn’t what you planned but to be honest, you made it through. And one day Annie will understand a little more and be a little less naughty.
Christine says:
And having kids, especially toddlers, definitely teaches you that every day is going to be different. Just when you plan to do 15 loads of laundry, they throw up all over you and your bed and you now have to spend the day cleaning all of your bedding instead! Lovely!
Amy C. says:
Yeah, they can sense it immediately. My boys always can when it is the anniversary of my Noah’s death on July 9th. I have learned over the 6 years or so to just not have any expectations on anyone’s behavior at all. John and I are going to act differently, the kids are going to be different. I call it, “I am going to turn my inner judge off” day and give myself a pass to just relax, not do anything, or take the kids to the park. Whatever. It has worked so far :). If there are some tantrums and time outs and tears (on all of our parts) then so be it. Parents shouldn’t ever have to deal with the death of their children so I think on their birth/death day(s) we should give ourselves a big old get out of jail free card. Oh yeah, and have a hot fudge sundae.
Meg says:
You are an amazing parent! Don’t be so hard on yourself. Sometimes our children know exactly what we need, and sometimes all they know how to do is push push push our buttons. Sometimes it’s all I can do not to walk around mumbling “cut me a fucking break” nonstop.
Annalisa says:
I’m lucky when I don’t feel the need to shout it lately. My kid is a delightfully smart and sensitive kid, the kind of kid who goes up to other crying children to make sure they’re okay, but she can still have a blind spot when it comes to her parents’ feelings. We can’t possibly be tired, sad, or upset.
Most of the time, I understand it from a developmental standpoint, but on particularly bad days it doesn’t matter why, it hurts just the same… but I have to get over it anyway. That, in a nutshell, is parenthood.
Sandy says:
My parents lost 2 children, 1 at birth and 1 at 1 week old. I was young when it happened and while their names were mentioned and we knew who they were, it never had the same impact on me as my parents. I didn’t know them and had never developed a relationship so they were just names to me and my siblings. Don’t feel bad if your daughter never feels the level of grief that you and your husband feel, because it won’t be the same to her, which is alright. We honored our lost siblings in our own way. My brother named his son after our lost brother, making my mom cry with happiness .Our siblings had no gravestones in the cemetery, just numbers, and after both my parents died, we had gravestones put on their grave, and I always put flowers on their graves, when stopping at my parents site. I am sure your daughter will feel as she gets older that it would have been nice to have an older sister, and she always has pictures to look at, but don’t feel bad if she never shares your level of understandable grief and sorrow.
Kim says:
If you want to chat more about this and how it effects these little ones as they get older, call me. It is hard. It is oh so hard.
Kat says:
Aww sweetheart, my heart breaks for you.
I think your hope for a brighter tomorrow (which Annie herself said!) must be so hard to balance with the loss of Maddie. You’re doing so well, Annie will understand when she’s older and you love all your kids something fierce.
Tomorrow can be both better and still sad. Remember that.
Love xx
Gwensarah says:
Oh Heather. I wish I could hug all of you. Toddlers pick up on things, it’s almost eerie. There was a different atmosphere on the 7th and Annie could sense the sadness but being three can’t separate the mood from herself. The toddler funk is pretty common in that situation but I know it just made the day even more difficult.
Norma says:
If only I could give you words of comfort…know that you and your family are in my thoughts and prayers.
Melissa says:
I’ve followed your blog for years and have been amazed by the strength you show through an unfathomable tragedy.
My brother died in an auto accident when he was 22. My daughter was born exactly 1 year later. She was such a saving grace to our family.
You and your family are always in my prayers!
Jennifer says:
One of the best things I’ve read about parenting is this:
“Kids give us a thousand chances to get it right”
While kids Annie’s age don’t really feel guilt, they also don’t hold a grudge and they just let it go. You may recognize those days when you feel like you fall short, but she doesn’t, you’re still her best Mama.
JT says:
That was heart-wrenching. I’m so sorry. Please don’t ever think you are a bad parent. You are a parent who something bad (incredibly, horribly bad) happened to. That does not mean you are not a good parent. You and Mike are one of the best examples of parents I can think of. To me, you two are role models for how to parent. My thoughts and prayers are with you three.
Sheri says:
Hi Heather.
You are not a bad parent. Not in the least bit.
My parents had two children before they adopted me, and then had my brother. Bruce was 1 year, 1 month and 11 days. He died on Christmas. Their second child, Jeffrey, was a little over two when he died, January 7, which is the Orthodox Christmas day. Crying is ok, having one “out of sorts” day is ok. My mom, too, tried (and succeeded) in putting on a brave front. Christmas was beautiful at our house. Absolutely perfect. I think she did it to honor their memory, and as I got older, she told me that she wanted us to be happy too.
Unfortunately, Annie is 3. She doesn’t “get” it. I knew I had two brothers since I can remember. They were in pictures in our house, we went to visit them at the cemetery etc. But I could not comprehend how my mom mourned them, how awful losing a child had to be until I was in my late teens….and I really didn’t mourn them until I had my own children.
Luckily, you have so many pictures and video (with sound). I would have loved to have that. Annie is so lucky in that aspect. My mom has told me stories. Bruce loved his bear..I found out that his bear later became my beloved Brown Teddy. I loved him to pieces–literally, he’s in a heep in a drawer in my dresser. Jeff was a fan of the “Beverly Hillbillies” TV show. He called them “the billies” and don’t you know, I watch that show whenever I can.
Maddie’s memory will always live on. And so will my brothers’. God bless you and your family.
Jaime says:
This ” I know that I rely too heavily on Annabel…she saved me in her pregnancy and birth but I have to stop using her as a life-preserver. She’s just a kid who was born into a heavy situation. I hope that one day she looks back and understands all of this, and how precious she is to me. I would draw a thousand hearts in the sky for her.” is so exactly how any loss mama feels about their next baby…this made me cry because I feel the same about Evangeline,and how she saved us, and is saving us each day, but that is a pretty heavy load for any three year old to bear, so I guess they reserve the right to flip out and act 3 now and then (more often then not these days in this house haha) hugs you both, your doing your best and your best is wonderful.
Alexandria says:
She will not remember any bad days.. Kids have a good day everyday. When they are mis behaving its normal for them to see us parents re act. However they soon get over it much easier than us. She will have SOO many good memories that you have created together, please dont worry about about her thinking of any other kind. Love you Heather!
Molly says:
I just wanted to add to the chorus of “be kind to yourself” and say that three was the first age I found myself getting really, really angry with my daughter, and I was not dealing with the circumstances you are dealing with. 3-year-olds can just be very vexing b/c they SEEM like fully rational people but oh, no. I felt like my daughter was on an emotional roller coaster (high highs, low lows) that whole year. Sometimes I would just look at her and say, Who ARE you?!
Be kind to yourself, mama, you are going through so much right now.
erin says:
Wow, what a poignant post. Really, this was so well written, full of emotion, and so real. Thank you for sharing. Our thoughts are with you through these difficult times.
Carla says:
Heather,
I just discovered your blog because of your article on surviving loss and marriages. My husband and I lost our 3rd son Owen on his 5 month birthday suddenly in 2012. He was a perfectly healthy boy. Our oldest son was actually born 11 days after Maddie so my heart breaks for you knowing all I have experienced with Connor. I was brought to tears by this post because like you, my daughter Reilly who was born after Owen passed “saved me” as well. I know it will be a mixed bag of emotions as she learns about Owen (she’s only 13 months now) but I hope like your said about Annabel Reilly one day understands the insane love I have for both her AND Owen. I too have to stop using Reilly as a life preserver.
Thanks for sharing your beautiful family and words with all of us.
From one grieving mother to another,
Carla
Heather says:
Carla, thank you for writing. I am so sorry to hear about your sweet Owen. Re: not using your daughter as a life preserver, you’ll get there. It took me a couple years…but I really needed that little bright-eyed reminder that life was worth living. So much love to you. xoxo